What I learned from trying 22 different whiskies

After trying 22 whiskies, I took a moment to review my notes and find patterns in what I liked and disliked.

Written by: Charlie Murphy

A collage of bottles and pours from the 22 whiskies in the founder's private Memolli journal.

I enjoy trying whiskies every once in a while. I think it is fascinating how you can get such a wide variety of flavors and aromas from a set of relatively simple ingredients: grain, water, yeast, and time. So far I’ve tried around 22 different types. Looking back through my notes, there are a few bottles that really stood out to me. Nikka Coffey Malt is hands-down my favorite whisky with its smooth, sweet, and malty taste. Oban Little Bay was another favorite. In contrast, there were some whiskies that I absolutely did not like, such as the Glendalough Single Malt 7yr Mizunara Finished; it had such an acrid, rubbery, and medicinal taste that I was tempted to dump the whole bottle.

How I tracked whiskies

I use this private journaling app I built called Memolli. I take a photo of the bottle, rate it, and write down what I thought. Since everything is private, the notes are informal and my photos are awkward. Since I am a very visual person, the photos are especially useful since they create a nice gallery of all the whiskies I tried. I used the same approach for my coffee journal and cider journal.


Memolli whisky photo grid showing bottles, pours, and personal tasting ratings
My whisky gallery in Memolli, with photos and star ratings from my tastings.


A few favorites, and plenty in the middle

Across the 22 whiskies, my average rating was 3.20 out of five. The figure below show the distribution of my ratings. Eight averaged exactly three stars. Only two averaged five: Nikka Coffey Malt and Oban Little Bay. Heaven Hill Bottled-In-Bond 7 Years Old sits just below them at 4.50.


Histogram of 22 whisky-average ratings. Half-star bins contain: 1 to under 1.5, 1 whisky; 1.5 to under 2, 0; 2 to under 2.5, 4; 2.5 to under 3, 0; 3 to under 3.5, 8; 3.5 to under 4, 2; 4 to under 4.5, 4; 4.5 through 5, 3.
Distribution of ratings I gave to each whisky, on a 1-5 star scale.


I like a little smokiness in whisky

I do not like overly smoky whiskies, they tend to be too string, bitter, and have a medicinal taste. I thought Ardbeg Uigeadail tasted basically like campfire ash mixed with vodka, so I gave it two stars. I also gave Nikka Miyagikyo Single Malt two stars for its overly smoky and bitter notes, even though I liked its aroma since it reminded me of Nikka Coffey Malt. In contrast, I really enjoyed Oban Little Bay and gave it five stars; it had a subtle smoky and meaty aroma with peach or apricot notes. I also really liked Oban 14 year whisky for similar reasons: it has very subtle smoke and meat notes.

What my tasting notes say about my preferences

Next, I wanted to see if certain tasting notes were associated with whiskies I rated higher or lower (see the figure below). The answer is yes. For example, whiskies I tagged with Smooth averaged 3.83 across nine reviews, and Sweet averaged 3.81 across eight reviews. Whereas, Bitter averaged 2.10 and Rubber averaged 2.00, both from five reviews.


Whisky ratings by recorded tasting note: Smooth 3.83 across 9 whiskies; Sweet 3.81 across 8; Vanilla 3.50 across 6; Spicy 3.42 across 6; Smoky 3.05 across 10; Bitter 2.10 across 5; Medicinal 2.00 across 3; Rubber 2.00 across 5. Small points show whisky averages and green circles show group means.
Shown are tasting notes recorded in at least three reviews.


The full whisky journal

Here is a table of all 22 whiskies I reviewed, with the names, producers, rating, and tasting notes I recorded.

The 22 whiskies I tried

From 28 review entries with an average rating of 3.2 out of 5 stars.

Showing all 22 whiskies

Whisky reviews with photos, average ratings, producers, and tasting notes
Photo Whisky Average rating Producer Tasting notes
Preview of 100% Rye 100% Rye 4.0 Great Jones Distilling Co
  • Citrus
  • Orange
  • Smooth
  • Spicy
Preview of Ardbeg Uigeadail Ardbeg Uigeadail 2.0 Ardbeg Distillery
  • Bitter
  • Rubber
  • Smoky
Preview of Dewar's 12 Years Blended Scotch Whisky Dewar's 12 Years Blended Scotch Whisky 3.0 Dewar's
  • Rubber
  • Smoky
  • Smooth
  • Spicy
Preview of Four Grain Bourbon Four Grain Bourbon 3.0 Great Jones Distilling Co
  • Spicy
  • Sweet
Preview of Heaven Hill Bottled-In-Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 7 Years Old Heaven Hill Bottled-In-Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey 7 Years Old 4.5 Heaven Hill
  • Smooth
  • Sweet
  • Vanilla
Preview of Japanese Harmony Japanese Harmony 3.0 Suntory
  • Smoky
  • Smooth
  • Vanilla
Preview of Loch Lomond 14 Inchmurrin Loch Lomond 14 Inchmurrin 2.0 Loch Lomond
  • Bitter
  • Medicinal
  • Rubber
  • Smoky
Preview of Nikka Coffey Grain Nikka Coffey Grain 4.0 Nikka Whisky (opens in a new tab)
  • Malty
  • Mild
  • Smooth
Preview of Nikka Coffey Malt Whisky Nikka Coffey Malt Whisky 5.0 Nikka Whisky (opens in a new tab)
  • Dark fruit
  • Malty
  • Smooth
  • Sweet
Preview of Nikka Miyagikyo Single Malt Nikka Miyagikyo Single Malt 2.0 Nikka Whisky (opens in a new tab)
  • Bitter
  • Rubber
  • Smoky
Preview of Oban 14 year whisky Oban 14 year whisky 3.5 Not recorded
  • Bitter
  • Smoky
  • Smooth
Preview of Oban Little Bay Oban Little Bay 5.0 Not recorded
  • Apricot
  • Smoky
  • Sweet
Preview of Old Grand-Dad Bonded Old Grand-Dad Bonded 3.0 Not recorded
  • Meaty
  • Savory
  • Smoky
Preview of Peated scotch cask bourbon Peated scotch cask bourbon 3.0 Great Jones Distilling Co
  • Medicinal
  • Smoky
Preview of Redbreast single pot still 12 yr Redbreast single pot still 12 yr 3.0 Redbreast Irish Whiskey Not recorded
Preview of Single Barrel Whiskey - Rye Single Barrel Whiskey - Rye 3.0 Not recorded
  • Spicy
  • Sweet
Preview of Single Malt 7yr - Mizunara Finished Single Malt 7yr - Mizunara Finished 1.0 Not recorded
  • Bitter
  • Chocolate
  • Medicinal
  • Rubber
Preview of Straight Bourbon Straight Bourbon 4.0 Great Jones Distilling Co
  • Spicy
  • Sweet
  • Vanilla
Preview of Tamnavulin Sherry Cask Edition Tamnavulin Sherry Cask Edition 4.0 Tamnavulin
  • Oak
  • Smoky
  • Smooth
  • Sweet
  • Vanilla
Preview of The-Balvenie Doublewood 12 year The-Balvenie Doublewood 12 year 3.0 Not recorded Not recorded
Preview of Tullamore D.E.W. Tullamore D.E.W. 3.5 Not recorded
  • Oak
  • Smooth
  • Spicy
  • Vanilla
Preview of White Label White Label 2.0 Dewar's
  • Sweet
  • Vanilla

What I would look for again

Nikka Coffey Malt remains my clear favorite, so I keep an eye out for similar whiskies that offer a smooth and malty taste. I learned I can also really enjoy lightly smoky whiskies, such as Oban Little Bay and Oban 14 year. I will still try peatier whiskies from time to time, but I will not buy full bottles and instead just do a sampling at a whisky bar (like Copper and Oak in NYC).

If you want to keep a similar record, the whisky journal guide explains how photos, ratings, and your own questions fit together.

Keep your own whisky journal

A photo, a rating, and a few words are enough to start remembering your favorites.

Try Memolli for free